Controversial New Breast Cancer Guidelines

Tools

Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

By Liz Tufts

Women across the country are reacting to new recommendations in the fight against breast cancer. A new government panel said practices you learned as a teenager could do more harm than good.

Thirty-four-year-old Mary Ortiz had breast pain a few months ago, so she called her doctor at Baystate's Comprehensive Breast Cancer.

"I figured I'd go get a mammogram because I have a history of breast cancer in my family," Ortiz said.

A mammogram found a cyst that was leaking fluid inside her breast.

"If I hadn't come here, I'd never would have found my lump whose to know how worse it could have gotten. I could have had cancer," she said.

A new government funded task force is recommending that patients the same age as Ortiz forgo mammograms until the age of 50. The panel said routine mammograms for younger women are not effective and that when screening starts at 40, there are more false positives leading to unnecessary biopsies.

Doctors at Baystate Medical Center strongly disagree.

"I don't think it's appropriate for a national society to say that we don't recommend," Dr. Grace Makari-Judson said.

Makari-Judson said mammograms are the one thing helping to drive down the breast cancer death toll.

"Every year for the last 20 years we've seen a steady improvement with a 2-3 percent reduction in the risk of dying from breast cancer," Makari-Judson said.

The panel is also recommending mammograms should only be done every two years for women ages 50-74, rather than getting them annually. As for those self breast exams, the task force said forget about them.

As for Ortiz, she said she is ignoring the recommendations and doing what is right for her.

"I think it's better for a women to come in between the ages of 35 and 40, maybe even younger especially if they are at risk for breast cancer," Ortiz said.

Monday, Nov 23 at 6:04 PM Nick wrote ...

The example of Ms Ortiz is irrelevant to the discussion, as she has symptoms and the taskforce recommendations only apply to asymptomatic, low-risk women. I would expect a news syndicate like CBS to understand the difference....

Friday, Nov 20 at 11:57 AM Rudy wrote ...

Actually there is a study that puts off PSA testing for men because is leads to false positives and unnessary treatment. I would rather deal with a false positive than miss something. It is true that the stress is bad for you, but death is so much worse. Caregivers educate your patients, knowledge helps people put issues in context, which will help them deal with the stress.

Thursday, Nov 19 at 12:34 PM Susan Megas wrote ...

The study was conducted by the US Preventive Services Task force (whoever they are) which is funded by federal money but which can act independently. It is a panel of 16 doctors,(whoever they are). Then, we hear from HHS Secretary Sebelius who said this task force does not set policy. So, who asked for their opinion and for what reason? If it smells like a rat....

Tuesday, Nov 17 at 8:13 PM Alicia wrote ...

I would like to know exactly who is on the government panel that made these recommendations. Predominately men? Predominately women? Equally represented? I wonder if the same recommendations will be forthcoming as to men having an annual PSA test.

Tuesday, Nov 17 at 7:37 PM mary wrote ...

did you check long island and all the wong women who have breast cancer. Many under 50 with young kids. Are the insurance companys trying to make money>>

Tuesday, Nov 17 at 7:36 PM Cheryl Pastika wrote ...

Sounds like the government is trying to lessen the population one breast cancer patient at a time and medicare won't have to pay either

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

CBS 3 Springfield and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

More Good Stuff

Advertisement

Weather

Icon
Current Temp 16.0 °F
Fair
Wind : Calm
Humidity : 84 %
Pressure : 1017.4 mb
More Weather

Weather

More Weather

On Demand

Stock Quotes

WHYN NewsTalk 560
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.