A Roman Catholic Alternative

Tools

Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

By Jennifer Thome

The Roman Catholic Diocese of Springfield announced this summer that 19 Catholic Churches are closing leaving many fighting to keep their places of worship open or looking for another church. We found local Catholic churches that are not part of the Roman Catholic diocese but are Catholic and run their church democratically.

Laurie Costello, member of National Catholic Church, says, "We came from the Roman Catholic Church and we just weren't happy with the way things ran."

Laurie Costello and her family changed churches 5 years ago when the Springfield Diocese closed the Roman Catholic school she grew up in.

Costello says, "We did fight to keep it open and we came to find out that no matter what you were going to do it has been decided."

But at St. Joseph's National Catholic Church in Westfield parishioners claim that would never happen to their church because they don't answer to the Springfield Diocese or the Vatican.

Costello says, "The parish won't close unless we vote on it."

Susan Teehan, a life-long member of St. Joseph's says, "The church is a democratic church. We own the property, the buildings."

Teehan's grandparents helped found St. Joseph's 80 years ago. She's been going to mass here since she was a little girl.

Teehan says, "I think other people feel they come to Sunday Mass and they leave and they have no voice in the church whereas we feel as if we are an important part of the church."

Father Sr. Joseph Soltysiak says, "The people of this church have very much a say in the affairs that go on."

Father Sr. Joseph Soltysiak has been the priest at St. Joseph’s for more than 15 years. He says everyone gets one vote, including him. But it's very much a Catholic church.

Father Sr. Soltysiak says, "We are a very high church. We are a Catholic Church. Our main method of worship is the Holy Mass Eucharist."

The National Catholic Church was founded in Pennsylvania in the late 1800's by Polish-Americans who broke away from the Roman Catholic Church partly because of disputes over who owned church property. Currently, there are 8 churches in Massachusetts and have 25-thousand members in the United States. It used to be called the Polish National Catholic Church until recently. They changed the name to welcome all people.

Father Sr. Soltysiak says, "The majority of people coming here and who become part of our family are people who left their Catholic faith and they can find it again here but not under the jurisdiction of Rome."

That's exactly what Laurie Costello and her family did and they found a new religious home.

There are differences between the National Catholic Church and the Roman Catholic Church. One of the most obvious is the priests can marry. Father Joe has several kids. One of them is also priest.

The National Catholic church is in dialogue with Rome.
The National Catholic Churches in Western Mass are in Chicopee, Northampton, South Deerfield, Ware and Westfield.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Dolores Robinson said on Monday, Nov 2 at 7:19 PM

I am a member of All Saints PNCC in Carngie, PA. To explain the PNCC as simply as possible, it is the best kept secret of Chtistian worship. Please come worship with us and see for yourself.

Deborah Ratajack, Lifelong member of the PNCC in Carnegie, PA said on Monday, Nov 2 at 12:13 PM

Although people of all ethnic backgrounds are welcomed as members, the legal name of the Church is still the Polish National Catholic Church and should not be confused with other independent churches with similar names. Apostolic succession is the key to our catholicity. This valid succession has been recognized by Rome.

Mark Stahelski said on Sunday, Nov 1 at 7:32 PM

Our church does believe in apostolic succession. As a matter of fact, the organizer of our church was consecrated a bishop by bishops of the Old Catholic Church, and it took place in Utrecht, Holland.

Anonymous said on Sunday, Nov 1 at 4:22 PM

I believe the Pope is the Spiritual leader of the Christian world, but not infallable. He has also had National Catholic Clergy serve Mass at the Basilica.

Anonymous said on Sunday, Nov 1 at 4:19 PM

It took me and my husband over a year to realize that the National Catholic Church is REALLY Catholic. Because of Apostolic succession we have not made our "own deals". We are the kind of Catholics I remember as a small child growing up Roman. After attending Mass at my newly found (16 years ago) church family, as a guest to see what I meant, his response was "Every Sunday I attend church, but today I attended MASS.

E.A. Garrett said on Friday, Oct 30 at 10:55 PM

Much depends upon how one defines the word Catholic: a Church which is in Apostolic Succession and believes itself to be part of the Church Universal: which would also include the Episcopal Church, the Old Catholic Church - Union of Utrecht, the Eastern Orthodox Churches (The Greek Orthodox Church, The Russian Orthodox Church and the Orthodox Church in America among others), and many Lutherans. Or solely a church which very much feels like the Roman Catholic Church such as the N.C.C.

Mark Stahelski said on Friday, Oct 30 at 4:23 PM

For those that are interested, there is a website to check out if you are interested. It is www.pncc.org

Thomas A. Szyszkiewicz said on Friday, Oct 30 at 12:55 PM

These are not alternatives to the Roman Catholic Church. These are people who have left and started their own deals. That doesn't make them a viable alternative. They cannot claim to have support from the Pope for what they do, and the last I checked, the Supreme Pontiff is one of the essential elements of the Roman Catholic Church.

Walter H Lasinski, Polish American Historian said on Friday, Oct 30 at 12:46 PM

Thank yopu for the excellent coverage on a Roman Catholic Alternative , , , ,

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

CBS 3 Springfield and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

More Good Stuff

Advertisement

Weather

Icon
Current Temp 50.0 °F
A Few Clouds
Wind : Calm
Humidity : 94 %
Pressure : 1019.5 mb
More Weather

Weather

More Weather

On Demand

Stock Quotes

WHYN NewsTalk 560
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.