Allegations of a Child Porn Cover Up at Local Library

Tools

Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

By Matthew Campbell

An assistant librarian blew the whistle on a patron who is accused of downloading child porn. But she didn't stop there. She speaks out against the higher-ups who, she says, tried to sweep the incident under the rug.

It was a December day at the Holyoke Library. Patrons were using the computer, until raw pornographic images pop up.

But the centerfold on the screen was a toddler.

"They were very sexually explicit photographs of a little girl, probably 3 or 4 years old. You couldn't see his face, but you could clearly see hers. It was almost like she was looking right at you," Wessels says.

Shocked, and staring back at the girl on the screen, were the patron, the assistant library director, and her boss, director, Maria Pagan.

"She thought by restarting the computer, that would take care of it," Wessels says.

Assistant Library Director, Carla Wessels, alleges her boss tried to delete the images and keep the incident quiet, by not reporting it.

"She kept saying over and over, the police are going to want to know a name. And she told me to just relax," Wessels says.

But Wessels couldn't. The images haunted the 5 year librarian.

"When I went home, Friday night after work, I was still really affected. All day through work all I could see were those images," Wessels says.

And that's when she decided to blow the whistle. It was 3 days later on a Monday morning.

"First thing when I got in, in the morning, I went into her office, and said pretty much the same thing when I called her Friday night. And she gave me the same response that the police are going to want to know a name and she even brought up the Patriot Act saying that as a library, we need to keep patrons names and addresses confidential," Wessels says.

Fearing the incident would never be reported, Wessels called police. Holyoke's Cyber Crimes unit seized the computer.

Hours later, the images Maria deleted were resurrected. The photos were brought back to life and the man who allegedly surfed for them was identified.

29 year old Michael Houle, who lives a block away from the library and the elementary school across the street, was arraigned on multiple counts of child pornography possession.

"I'm just trying to do what's right and to have people in the higher lever of authority than me not want to be on my side or tell me I did the right thing, is sad," Wessels says.

So CBS 3 went to the people in power, visiting Maria Pagan at her home, and Chairwoman of the Board, Ellen Moriarty.

After repeated attempts, CBS 3 caught up with Pagan at the library.

"What about the allegations that you told the librarians not to do anything about it," we asked.

"That's what they're saying, I'm not going to say either way," Pagan says.

The Library Director still would not admit timing was an issue.

"The police was called, right," Pagan says. "The person was caught, so time doesn't matter," she states.

But Police Chief Anthony Scott says timing is everything.

"If they deleted files, it would've caused problems, but because of the actions of the assistant librarian, we were able to get the info and secure the computer," Scott says.

But when asked by CBS 3, Pagan is still unsure police involvement was the right thing to do.

"Did you follow the manual that day," we asked.

"Didn't even think of doing it," Pagan states.

"Why not," we respond.

"It was just a reaction," she says.

"Do you regret not calling police earlier," we ask.

"Probably, probably," Pagan says, shrugging us off.

After the incident, the library conducted it's own investigation. The results aren't public, because under city law, drafted in the 1900s, the library is treated as a private organization.

"The library is separate. It's run by a board of trustees," confirms Holyoke Mayor Michael Sullivan.

We ask Pagan more questions.

"Is child safety or the reputation of the library more important?"

"Child safety," she responds.

"Then why didn't you call police as soon as you saw those pictures," we ask.

"It was probably a reaction. That's just it," Pagan says.

But Wessels is afraid it won't be the last time, she'll be calling police.

"I think it could easily happen again," Wessels says.

Our investigation discovered no changes at the library. Sex offender posters are not put up. There are no new firewalls in the library computers, nor are there any new policies for dealing with illegal activities.

Friday, Jul 3 at 1:41 PM Deena wrote ...

I think that Maria & Ellen should DEFINITELY be fired as a result of thier tampering with evidence, refusing to cooperate with those seeking to solve this crime, & by their actions, placing Ms. Wessels, other staff, & patrons in harms way.

Sunday, Jul 5 at 7:56 PM Diana wrote ...

We need more people like Carla Wessels who put the welfare of children ahead of their own job security. She followed her conscience and will be able to sleep at night.

Monday, Jul 6 at 6:04 AM Jim wrote ...

Too easy to just "delte" things and pretend they never happened. people don't want to get involved and that's why this country is on the slippery slope down the tubes!

Monday, Jul 6 at 11:23 AM Michael wrote ...

I voted Democrat in last election. I believe in Gay rights. I believe pot should be legal. I also believe the library management that did not report this crime should be charged for aiding, destruction of evidence and complicity in a crime.

Sunday, Jul 26 at 9:24 PM Christina wrote ...

The world needs more "Carla Wessels" in it! Obviously, the Director had other motives for NOT wanting to report this crime! Shame on her and the others who chose NOT to report this!

Friday, Jul 31 at 1:17 PM Holyoke Friend wrote ...

HPL board of directors and city paid library director should be held accountable - cover up an act of complicity that should be un-covered up. Are there no consequences for the HPL library director, Maria Pagan and the board of directors, headed by Ellen Moriarty? Public confidence in the HPL as an institution that protects the public interest, needs to be restored. Elected officials should call for public hearing and criminal investigation. No city support without HPL accountability.

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

CBS 3 Springfield and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

More Good Stuff

Weather

Icon
Current Temp 32.0 °F
Fair
Wind : Calm
Humidity : 99 %
Pressure : 1022.2 mb
More Weather

Weather

More Weather

On Demand

Stock Quotes

WHYN NewsTalk 560
This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.